The Treasury Department says IRS Direct File is a failed program. Its creators are worried DOGE is going to kill it.

J Studios/Getty, Rosa MarΓa FernΓ‘ndez Rz/Getty, Tyler Le/BI
- IRS Direct File is the nation's first free tax filing system, meant to ease the pain and fees of complex filings.
- Employees who worked on it are worried that DOGE wants to kill the two-year-old program to save money.
- A Treasury Department official told BI it was a failed program and said its fate was up in the air.
The future of IRS Direct File looks grim as a DOGE official eyes cuts and the Treasury Department dismissed the free tax filing system as a failed program.
Sam Corcos, a DOGE official and one of the group's public faces, has expressed skepticism about IRS Direct File, according to a recently departed federal employee. Corcos has said he thinks it should be shut down, according to two people who were told about his thinking by others close to him.
A senior Treasury official told Business Insider it was a failed and disappointing program used by a small fraction of the nation's taxpayers. No decisions have been made about its future, the official added.
The uncertainty has disappointed people who believe Direct File is emblematic of the very things that DOGE is supposed to be building.
Its purpose is to offer a tech solution to file taxes directly to the US government quickly, bypassing fees to for-profit software companies. A December 2024 IRS report found that taxpayers spent around $160 and eight hours preparing their taxes.
"On the one hand, you have a broader ambition through the DOGE to automate IRS operations and create a more online IRS that would justify the significant reductions in force that are underway," Danny Werfel, who served as IRS commissioner until January, said. "On the other hand, you have a very strong contingency in Congress and an industry who believes that this activity should be the exclusive domain of the private sector."
Critics of the tool say it's too costly, and wasn't implemented legally. Representatives for H&R Block and Intuit, which makes the popular tax prep software TurboTax, said that free tax preparation has been available to Americans for years.
It's not clear whether the views of DOGE or Corcos will affect Trump administration policy. Elon Musk, DOGE's de facto face, claimed in February he had "deleted" a government agency that helped build Direct File; that came months after he had reportedly eyed creating an app Americans could use to file their taxes.
The Treasury senior official's characterization of the program appears to diverge from previous statements about its future. During confirmation hearings, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent committed to preserving the program through the 2025 tax season.
The program presents a DOGE dilemma: While it's a potential budget item to be cut, and still getting off the ground, it's also an automated and efficient tech tool. Advocates say that saving or even bolstering it could exemplify the DOGE way β if it's allowed to stay afloat.
Scale it or kill it?
About a fifth of American taxpayers β or 32 million people β are eligible to use Direct File this year, and the program's advocates are eager to get the word out.
Last year's pilot program saw high satisfaction ratings. Just under 141,000 people used Direct File to do their taxes, and 90% of them rated their experience "excellent" or "above average," an IRS report showed. Eighty-six percent said it increased their trust in the IRS. A December 2024 survey by the Urban Institute of more than 7,000 adults found that 73% of tax filers are interested in using Direct File β but 68% of filers said they didn't know enough about the program to feel comfortable using it.
One Treasury official pointed to their favorite user feedback quote from someone who used it to complete their return: "I don't cry when I do my taxes using Direct File."
The IRS expected between 920,000 and 3.7 million users this year. The agency hasn't reported usage so far, and said data on its website traffic can't be compared to last year because of a change in how the data was collected.
Though the concept is popular and early usage signs are encouraging, awareness is a big issue. Many Americans heard about the tool for the first time after Musk's post about the deletion.
Some people took that to mean that the program was being axed, and former government employees said Musk's post undercut the IRS's messaging that the program would be permanent. Google search volume for "direct file" peaked the day after Musk's post.
Some people inside and outside the government said the IRS could do more to help spread the word. While the agency has mentioned Direct File in several press releases, sometimes alongside the Free File program that gives middle- and low-income people free access to private-sector tax prep tools, it hasn't hosted any calls with the media on Direct File since October 2024. Finding it from the IRS homepage can take multiple clicks.
"If you give a program some time, growth will increase and then something like that can take off," said a Treasury official who wasn't authorized to speak to the media. Referring to the move from paper returns to filing electronically, they added, "Imagine if they had killed e-file in 1989 or 1988 before it really even was able to get going. This is a program where we've seen people really satisfied."
Direct File began in 2022 when Congress committed $15 million to study a way to file taxes directly with the IRS online, without complicated tax forms. Within a year, a prototype was ready. Dozens of tech workers from the IRS and other federal offices teamed up to build Direct File, which went live last year for a limited number of taxpayers.
"We effectively launched a startup in the IRS," said a person who worked on the program.
'Unnecessary, problematic, costly, and illegitimate'
Republican critics of the program have said the agency overstepped its legal authority when it decided to make Direct File permanent.
"The IRS does not have unlimited resources and should focus on improving information technology systems, data privacy, and long-standing customer service issues," Sens. Mike Crapo and John Barrasso wrote in a July letter to Werfel, the former IRS commissioner. "It should not be focused on unilaterally expanding its own power, without congressional approval, through a permanent government tax preparation scheme that is unnecessary, problematic, costly, and illegitimate."
They have also said the program could cost billions of dollars, although the inspector general who covers the IRS reported last month that it identified $33.4 million in spending related to running the program last year, a number it said "may not capture all the costs."
Despite public confusion, there are signs that interest in the program is growing as tax day approaches: The number of active users on directfile.irs.gov over the week ending on April 7 was about 8% of the total number of people going to the IRS homepage, compared to about 5% for the 90 days before.
"On the one hand, lots of people using and liking Direct File would help protect the program," said Vanessa Williamson, a researcher at the Brookings Institution.
On the other hand, she said, "We're really in uncharted waters in terms of how decisions are being made at a federal level."
Have a tip? Contact these reporters via Signal at 314-971-1627 and julianakaplan.33, or email at jnewsham@businessinsider.com and jkaplan@businessinsider.com. Use a personal email address and a nonwork device; here's our guide to sharing information securely.