โŒ

Reading view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.

I tried on similar sweaters from Banana Republic, Old Navy, and Gap. One store offered an unmatched shopping experience.

A composite image of a man wearing three different black sweaters and taking a photo of himself using a phone.
I tried on similar sweaters at Banana Republic, Old Navy, and Gap.

Mike Vulpo

  • I tried on similar black sweaters at Banana Republic, Old Navy, and Gap.
  • I liked the style of the Gap sweater, and was even more impressed with the price.
  • Although the option from Banana Republic was expensive, I thought it offered the best overall value.

Whenever it's time to put up Christmas lights or adjust to daylight-saving time, I typically look through my drawers and discover I need more winter clothes.

This year, I made finding reliable and versatile sweaters a priority. So, I turned to three Gap Inc.-owned retailers โ€” Banana Republic, Old Navy, and Gap โ€” to find a black sweater that was both cozy and stylish.

Going into this trip, I knew the items at Banana Republic would likely be a splurge for my budget. I expected the clothes at Old Navy and Gap to be more in my price range, but I arrived at a Los Angeles-area mall, ready to open my wallet and purchase items I could wear for seasons to come.

However, I was quickly reminded that price isn't the only factor to consider when shopping for new clothes.

I started my shopping journey at Banana Republic.
The exterior of a Banana Republic store with the doors open.
Banana Republic has over 400 stores worldwide.

Mike Vulpo

I started my journey at Banana Republic, which has more than 400 stores worldwide and is known for its high-quality, expertly crafted collections.

I really enjoyed my experience here.
12 stacks of different-colored sweaters on a table, with a sign that reads, "Italian Merino Wool."
All of the sweaters at Banana Republic were perfectly folded.

Mike Vulpo

Immediately after entering the store, I spotted a table set with perfectly folded sweaters.

As I was browsing for my size, an employee checked on me and asked if I was finding everything I needed โ€” a question I only received once during my mall visit.

Although I feared Banana Republic would have pushy and overwhelming sales associates, I felt relaxed and comfortable while scanning the store.

After grabbing an $80 sweater, which was on sale for 40% off, I headed for the dressing room.

I really liked the fit and feel of this sweater, made of Italian Merino wool.
Mike takes a photo of himself in a dressing-room mirror while wearing a black sweater.
I really liked the crew-neck sweater from Banana Republic.

Mike Vulpo

I instantly felt cozy wearing the classic crew-neck sweater, knitted from the company's signature all-season Italian Merino wool.

Although my usual medium size fit like a glove, a large also would've worked if I wanted a looser fit or to layer a shirt underneath.

I was quickly sold on the sweater, but I wanted to see what options were available at the other two stores.

Next, I visited Old Navy.
The exterior of an Old Navy store in a mall.
Old Navy has over 1,200 stores around the world.

Mike Vulpo

With less than an hour until the mall closed, I headed to one of the world's largest apparel brands โ€” Old Navy.

The chain, which has over 1,200 stores worldwide, offers a range of clothing options for the whole family.

The shopping experience here was a little more chaotic than the one I'd had at Banana Republic.
Stacks of different-colored sweaters, cardigans, and pants on three shelves at Old Navy. The middle row has a sign that says "now 50% off," and the bottom row has one that says "now 40% off."
The sweaters were mixed between rows of pants and cardigans.

Mike Vulpo

Searching the store for a black sweater was a bit of a hunt, but I eventually found one row mixed in between pants and cardigans.

However, I appreciated the store's use of clothing-size stickers on its sweaters. As a result, I didn't have to pull out handfuls of clothing to see if my size was available.

I was also delighted to see Old Navy delivering on price. Normally sold for $35, the black sweater I grabbed was on sale for 50% off.

I wasn't a fan of the Old Navy option.
Mike takes a photo of himself in a dressing-room mirror while wearing a black sweater.
This sweater seemed like it would easily pick up dust and cat hair.

Mike Vulpo

Once I tried on the crew-neck sweater in the fitting room, I feared its 60% cotton and 40% polyester material would easily pick up things like dust and cat hair.

The sweater also felt tighter around my neck, making me question if I wanted โ€” and needed โ€” to size up. As of now, this sweater was headed back to the rack.

I ended my trip with a stop at Gap.
The exterior of a Gap store in a mall.
Gap has over 580 locations across the US and Asia.

Mike Vulpo

Last but not least, I rushed into Gap before the mall closed. The retailer, which has over 580 locations across the US and Asia, has always felt like a midway point between Banana Republic and Old Navy in terms of price and quality.

Of all the stores I visited, Gap had the least number of options available.
A stack of black, green, and navy-blue sweaters on a shelf.
Gap had less options than Banana Republic and Old Navy did.

Mike Vulpo

Upon entering the store, I discovered that Gap had the fewest number of sweaters available. With less than a handful to choose from in various colors, I was relieved they still had my size ready to try on in black.

I was also delighted to see that Gap was having a sale. The sweaters were marked down to $19 from their original price of $50.

The sweater from Gap was the most versatile I tried on.
Mike takes a photo of himself in a dressing-room mirror while wearing a black sweater.
The sweater from Gap was made of 100% cotton.

Mike Vulpo

Made of 100% cotton, this sweater was the longest of the three I tried on.

The textured style also made me feel like this was a more versatile option, allowing me to dress up for an evening event or keep things casual for an afternoon running around town.

Overall, I thought Banana Republic provided the best value.
A composite image of a man wearing three different black sweaters and taking a photo of himself using a phone.
I'll definitely return to Banana Republic again.

Mike Vulpo

Although I came close to purchasing the Gap sweater at the end of the night โ€” it was technically the best savings by far โ€” I ultimately loved my Banana Republic shopping experience the best.

The customer service, store presentation, and comfort of the sweater I tried on left me wanting to return as soon as possible. Plus, the price was reasonable for my budget โ€” not triple digits like I feared going into the store.

I'll admit I would be satisfied with Gap's sweater, and Old Navy's option would also do the job. Sometimes, however, you have to fork over a few extra bucks and do what looks โ€” and feels โ€” right.

Read the original article on Business Insider

โŒ