Politics

What Are the Masculine Virtues?

Klay explains why Hegseth’s version of manhood is bad for men (and the military), why warfare can never be stripped of its moral meaning, and why love is the greatest masculine virtue.

✦ Extractive summary — built from the sources' own reporting•From 1 source•1 min read•Updated November 15, 2026, 2:00 PM UTC
Key points
  • I’d like a different masculine ideal than the ones being offered today.
  • These efforts are taking place at a time when many young American men are facing a very real crisis, but they don’t seem to have landed among their target audience: Male voters younger than 30 swung 40 percent toward Democrats in the midterms, one of the election’s largest such demographic shifts.
  • In this episode of The Permanent Questions, David Brooks talks with Phil Klay, a Marine Corps veteran, National Book Award–winning novelist and story writer, and close observer of the effects that our 21st-century wars have had on American soldiers.

Personally, I’m not particularly thrilled with what Pete Hegseth and Donald Trump are selling.

You get a very different masculine ideal, which is about compassion and peace.

Additional details
  • It purports to be a solution to our cultural problems—that we’re gonna have a bunch of manly men and womanly women and we’ll return to a kind of gender relations that, according to some people, were healthier.
  • That means there are a lot of young men—and women—who’ve been through those wars, who fought in those wars, who are trying to live with the consequences.
  • It seems to me there have been a series of social ideals that young men in particular were supposed to follow and this was held up as their social ideal.
  • The following is a transcript of the episode: David Brooks: There are at least three important things going on in America right now.
  • Then you get my hero, the gentleman in Trollope, and Trollope novels always revolve around a gentleman who is not….

How this summary was made: extractive summary — built from the sources' own reporting. It is drawn only from the reporting of the sources listed below — read the originals for full detail. How we summarize →

Advertisement

Every article behind this summary — 1 article from 1 outlet