The Only Thing Nathan Fielder Won’t Show
The blockbuster documentary, created by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, is about Elizabeth Holmes, the former CEO of the blood-test company Theranos, and the days before she reports to federal prison after being convicted of fraud.
- [ Read: How did Nathan Fielder pull this off?
- But the executives react as if no one in history has ever suggested such an untoward thing.
- But Evans, her partner and the father of her two children, manages to come out of the film looking worse than she does—not because he committed any crime, but because he wanted to get paid for participating in the documentary.
I get why viewers would find the idea objectionable: How dare Evans and Holmes profit from a documentary that exists only because she was convicted of a crime?
The documentary stages a reenactment of a scene in which Evans negotiates with Fielder and Oppenheim and some A24 executives.
- The film spends much of its second half interrogating Holmes and Evans’s financial motive, and what that reveals about their honesty and transparency (though a title card at the end reveals that Evans gave up his profit share before the film was released after all).
- It’s an intimate film about my attempts to reconcile with the Italians who misunderstood me, the media that vilified me, and, most of all, the prosecutor who threw me in prison and later agreed to meet with me.
- I didn’t love the idea of funneling money toward some of the very people who’d traumatized me, but one photo in particular—of Christopher shielding my face inside the car while the paparazzo is reflected in the window—was too evocative not to include.
- (Daniele Mascolo / Reuters) One of Christopher’s primary motivations to make this film was to reveal the version of me he knew—the wife and mother struggling to make sense of her past, as opposed to the “public figure,” the subject of a true-crime story that had been told many times before.
- Reason called the deal a “crooked bargain.” The Los Angeles Times explained to readers that paying documentary subjects is unusual under “traditional journalistic standards.” It is, of course, true that introducing a pay-to-play dynamic to a truth-seeking mission has the potential to warp the incentives of everyone involved.
How this summary was made: extractive summary — built from the sources' own reporting. It is drawn only from the reporting of the sources listed below — read the originals for full detail. How we summarize →