The Great New York–Florida Debate
They tell me it’s easier to get a driver’s license in Florida at the DMV than it is up there.” The difference between New York’s and Florida’s spending doesn’t actually come down to roads; it comes down to the two biggest items in most state budgets: education and, especially, Medicaid.
- According to the Urban Institute’s demographically adjusted National Assessment of Education Progress, Florida scores much better in fourth-grade reading and math, while New York scores slightly better in eighth-grade reading and math.
- According to estimates from the National Association of State Budget Officers, New York’s program for fiscal year 2025 added up to $89 billion, compared with $34 billion for Florida.
- New York spends about $32,000 per K–12 student, the highest of any state, whereas Florida schools spend roughly $13,000 per student, the sixth-lowest in the country.
(Only a small portion of this gap can be explained by New York’s higher cost of living.) The difference in benefits is even more stark: New York spends three and a half times as much on employee benefits per pupil as Florida does.
- While many of his fellow Republican governors were being washed out of office by the midterm blue wave, Florida’s Ron DeSantis spent Election Day reasserting the superiority of red-state governance.
- Johnson envisioned Medicaid as a way to extend “the miracle of healing” to the poor, but in Florida, the poor aren’t covered unless they’re elderly, a child, or a parent living with their child.
- That’s more than twice the budget.” And yet, he argued, if you live in New York, “you’re not getting better roads or infrastructure.
- But the perennial debate about which state’s taxpayers get more for their money cannot be answered just by comparing budget lines.
- Teachers in New York are paid an average of $99,000, the second-highest rate in the country.
How this summary was made: extractive summary — built from the sources' own reporting. It is drawn only from the reporting of the sources listed below — read the originals for full detail. How we summarize →