‘Strict cell phone bans seem to plug about half of that leak’: Harvard economist finds locking up students’ phones adds 1–2 weeks of learning a year
“Strict cell phone bans seem to plug about half of that leak,” said Kane in a statement.
- The abandonment of test-based accountability and out-of-school social media use could be most costly for them.” Not everyone is sold A National Bureau of Economic Research study found in May that strict bans had close to zero effect on test scores.
- It found signs that state-mandated bans in 22 states raised reading and math scores last year, but researchers cautioned that these findings might be confounded by pre-existing trends in the states implementing bans.
- As for the other half, Kane told Fortune “the two main suspects are declining test-based accountability following the replacement of the No Child Left Behind Act and out-of-school social media use.” He added: “One of the big mysteries our study did not explain is the precipitous drop for the lowest achieving students.
Making students lock their phones in pouches for the school day adds one to two weeks of learning a year, according to a national study released Tuesday.
Tom Kane, an economist and education professor who serves as the director of Harvard’s Center for Education Policy Research, released an Education Scorecard which traced a “learning recession” back to 2013, years before the pandemic.
- Tom Dee, a Stanford professor and co-author of that study, told NPR he considers the early results on phone bans “largely disappointing.” Neither study has been published in a peer-reviewed journal.
- The argument has money riding on it: New York and 16 other states put bell-to-bell bans in place last school year, and Kane puts the cost of a pouch at about $25 a student.
- A better test, he said, would compare schools that already had strict bans of their own with schools in the same state that adopted bans only after the state law passed.
- The two also measured different things: the NBER study pooled school-level mean test scores at several thousand Yondr-adopting schools, while the Harvard study used student-level scores at the 844 schools that use both Yondr pouches and tests administered by NWEA.
- “Given the difference in post-pandemic recovery in the states with and without bans, it will be hard for anyone—not just us—to discern the effect of the bans by comparing across states,” Kane said.
How this summary was made: extractive summary — built from the sources' own reporting. It is drawn only from the reporting of the sources listed below — read the originals for full detail. How we summarize →