Skims’ $148 advent calendar flop wasn’t a stunt, marketers say—but store credit may not win back Kim Kardashian’s angry customers
“We might be on track for the worst advent calendar I’ve ever opened,” content creator Kayla Ryan said in a TikTok video this week, referring to the $148 Skims 12-day advent calendar that customers have been ripping apart for the past several days.
- The catch, according to the email buyers received, is that a cash refund means sending the calendar back, while shoppers who opt for store credit keep it.
- The $148 box held keychains, bobby pins, scrunchies, and hair ties—but none of the bodysuits or loungewear that made Kim Kardashian’s company so popular.
- Metcalfe expects Skims to weather the cost of a single calendar, but the bigger risk is what customers remember long term.
In response to the online outrage, the company “personally contacted every customer who purchased the calendar and offered them a choice of a full refund or a SKIMS credit to put towards other products,” a spokesperson told other outlets.
- Ben Metcalfe, founder of BlackFire Marketing, told Fortune that offering store credit is “smarter than just a refund” because it gets shoppers back in the door.
- Why some execs think the marketing stunt theory falls apart But other marketers and consumer researchers who spoke with Fortune don’t buy it.
- A 2025 study by Northwestern Kellogg School of Management lecturer Ata Jami also found shoppers are more likely to spend money they get back from returns, and more inclined to splurge with it, since it doesn’t sting the way spending regular cash does.
- “This is a product that never got checked against what shoppers think $148 should buy.” Zappi’s research shows just one in 10 consumers sticks solely to name brands, suggesting brand loyalty alone won’t carry a weak product.
- Customers who feel ripped off don’t spend like someone holding a birthday gift card, they say, and new social-listening data shows the negativity sticking around even as the online chatter dies down.
How this summary was made: extractive summary — built from the sources' own reporting. It is drawn only from the reporting of the sources listed below — read the originals for full detail. How we summarize →