SCOTUS gives DEI a boost after national assault
Trump has led a top-down campaign to undermine federal and corporate DEI efforts, disputes over state policies have also crept onto the national stage.
- Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals panel ruled in May that challengers were likely to succeed on their First Amendment claim that their grants were terminated because of the "perceived expression of DEI, DEIA, or environmental justice viewpoints." That decision partly upheld a preliminary injunction from U.S.
- The big picture: The denials mark a reprieve after years of backlash against DEI, though the justices stopped short of settling the underlying constitutional debates.
- District Judge Rita Lin reinstating grants terminated over perceived DEI-related viewpoint, while reversing relief for a separate group.
What we're watching: Both in the courts and in the public arena, disputes over the federal administration and state leaders' handling of DEI initiatives are still playing out with many more sure to come.
Driving the news: The justices rejected President Trump's bid to revive cuts to federal research grants awarded to University of California researchers over their perceived DEI-related viewpoints.
- One of those Monday decisions set back President Trump's administration push to cancel swaths of DEI-related research grants.
- But on Monday, a high court that hasn't always sided with DEI initiatives declined to further some key debates — for now.
- The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear three conservative appeals tied to battles over diversity, equity and inclusion, leaving lower-court rulings intact in disputes over federal research grants, medical training and transgender-related speech.
- Case in point: The Supreme Court also declined to hear a challenge from the anti-trans Gays Against Groomers against Colorado lawmakers' restrictions on misgendering and deadnaming during legislative hearings.
- Thomas' argument indicates there may be an appetite for a similar question about government speech in the future: "A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny," he wrote.
How this summary was made: extractive summary — built from the sources' own reporting. It is drawn only from the reporting of the sources listed below — read the originals for full detail. How we summarize →