Gerrymandering Worked
“Even if the gerrymanders didn’t produce the sort of absolute gains that Republicans had hoped, they absolutely worked in terms of preventing a fair or more proportional change to the status quo,” Justin Levitt, a professor at Loyola Law School, told me.
- Do they give a Nobel Prize for attempted chemistry?” Similarly, the idea now is that because attempts to insulate Republican incumbents from democracy and deprive Black voters of political influence failed, no harm was done.
- “Republicans still gained anywhere from four to seven seats as a result of the new maps, even if they didn’t pay off as Republicans hoped,” The New York Times reported in a preliminary analysis last weekend.
- With a “hypothetical party-blind map, like one drawn by computer simulations,” the Times noted, “Democrats almost certainly would have won a majority of Texas’ House seats.” Votes are still being counted, so the numbers remain preliminary.
Republicans got wiped out in the midterms, which means that fears about gerrymandering, diminished Black representation, and the undermining of democracy were all completely overblown.
- But based on what we know so far, thanks to mid-decade redistricting, only eight of Florida’s 28 congressional districts will go to Democrats, despite Democrats winning about 48 percent of the vote.
- It is true that some gerrymanders backfired by making the wrong assumptions about the midterm electorate and spreading Republican votes too thin; this happened in Ohio and North Carolina.
- But they succeeded in both limiting the damage and keeping huge majorities in the delegations of states where Democrats came close to winning or won more than half of the votes.
- Some discrepancy can be explained by political geography—Democratic votes cluster in cities or suburbs while Republican voters are more rural and spread out—but not all of it.
- Eight out of nine congressional districts will go to Republicans in Tennessee, with one close race still uncalled, after Democrats won about 44 percent of the vote.
How this summary was made: extractive summary — built from the sources' own reporting. It is drawn only from the reporting of the sources listed below — read the originals for full detail. How we summarize →