Fan Letters: Let’s Keep Any Criticism Fair And Balanced
[email protected] Dear Roker Report, I’ve been disgusted by the amount of vitriolic, foul mouthed (letters to Roker Report) criticism from so-called Sunderland supporters, aimed at the management and the players.
- The manager knows we’re not playing well, and the players know they’re not playing well, but at this stage of the season, do they deserve this amount of criticism and its vitriolic nature?
- Xhaka didn’t do himself any favours during the summer with rumours of his desire to move to Chelsea swirling, and Alderete hasn’t looked right since returning from the World Cup.
- When things are not going your way, they really aren’t going your way — let’s take the three goals at Coventry.
I agree, everybody is entitled to criticise but let’s make sure that the content is constructive and logically argued but more importantly, delivered with the respect this squad of players and management have earned and deserve.
Why would any player want to sign for Sunderland only to be subjected to this level of criticism?
- SUNDERLAND, ENGLAND - NOVEMBER 8: Sunderland fans applaud Chelsea's Jordan Henderson as he is substituted during the Premier League 2026/27 match between Sunderland and Chelsea FC at Stadium of Light on November 8, 2026 in Sunderland, United Kingdom.
- I prefer to look at our current position like this: we’re in the quarter finals of the Carabao Cup, unbeaten in Europe and with twenty nine games to go in the Premier League, we’re seven points off a European qualifying place.
- The greatest support I ever witnessed at a football match was from the magnificent, loyal and genuine supporters of Sunderland on a Thursday night (19 May 1977) at Goodison Park for Everton versus Sunderland.
- Ultimately, the Sunderland fans have reacted to what they’ve seen on the pitch this season so far, and it’s not unreasonable to claim that on too many occasions, the players haven’t played up to the standards that were set last season and that needed to be replicated if we wanted to enjoy a competitive 2026/2027 campaign.
- There’s every chance that we’ll eventually haul ourselves out of the relegation picture and that this season could bring success, but there had been very little to cheer about during the opening months of the campaign, with a string of sub-par performances, glaring individual errors and poor results.
How this summary was made: extractive summary — built from the sources' own reporting. It is drawn only from the reporting of the sources listed below — read the originals for full detail. How we summarize →