An obscure Marxist critic who died fleeing the Nazis saw ‘aura farming’ coming 90 years ago—and why you can’t afford to see the Knicks or Taylor Swift
Gen Z calls it “ aura farming.” Live Nation calls it “being there.” The hottest idea in the AI economy belongs to a Marxist critic who wrote his ideas in exile, never saw a royalty, and died tragically—a total obscurity in his own time.
- Being there in person is irreplaceable, and that’s driving global demand for live music.” For executives and investors, the aura is becoming one of the few things AI can’t make cheaper, and money is following it into live seats, sports teams, and the top of the art market: anything with a time and a place attached.
- The German-Jewish critic fled Germany in 1933 and spent most of the rest of the decade in exile, much of it in Paris, working on an unfinished history of the city’s 19th-century glass-roofed shopping arcades, forerunners of the mall.
- Authenticity, in his definition, is everything a thing carries “from its beginning, ranging from its substantive duration to its testimony to the history which it has experienced.” A copy can carry the image but not that history: “The presence of the original is the prerequisite to the concept of authenticity,” he wrote.
Hannah Arendt, a great journalist and critic in her own right, who coined the phrase “ the banality of evil ” and covered Adolf Eichmann’s trial for the New Yorker, selected it for the collection Illuminations, and wrote the introduction.
- With generative AI pushing exhibition value close to zero—a chatbot can turn out a passable image, song, or article in seconds—the premium moves to whatever exhibition can’t deliver.
- “Cult value” belonged to the original made for ritual, which he wrote “would seem to demand that the work of art remain hidden.” “Exhibition value” belonged to whatever could be shown to as many people as possible.
- “You can’t stream or replicate the energy of thousands of fans singing together as they watch their favorite artist.
- “In a world of endless screens and AI-generated everything, the one thing that can’t be replicated is being there,” he said on Nov.
- Walter Benjamin was obsessed with the subject of the “aura” in the 1930s, and he thought mass reproduction would kill it.
How this summary was made: extractive summary — built from the sources' own reporting. It is drawn only from the reporting of the sources listed below — read the originals for full detail. How we summarize →