Health

An Almost Entirely Unregulated Corner of the Health-Care Workforce

Stockman said she paid $2,500 for the doula’s services: “What a waste.” Stockman is one of several women I interviewed who have had dissatisfying experiences with a birth doula, a role that makes up a fast-growing and largely unregulated part of the health-care workforce.

✦ Extractive summary — built from the sources' own reporting•From 1 source•2 min read•Updated November 17, 2026, 12:30 PM UTC
Key points
  • Or, a doula might have no training at all: Although some states require doulas to be certified in order to be reimbursed by Medicaid, there are no national standards for doula training or qualification.
  • A few weeks before her due date, Gumpert said her doula talked with her about “birth imprinting,” a debunked, pseudoscientific idea that the circumstances of a person’s birth permanently shape their nervous system.
  • Other women I spoke with also said that their doulas dispensed questionable counsel; one mother in Seattle told me that her doula had encouraged her to decline pitocin, a medication that can induce contractions, against medical advice.

And for some mothers, “having a doula present at their birth drives them to become a doula.” [ Read: The states where it’s riskier to have a baby ] Doula training varies considerably; a given doula might have a year of instruction or a couple of days’ worth.

Additional details
  • Gumpert’s doula left her hospital room while she was in labor to go see another client, which made Gumpert feel as though the doula was “abandoning me and completely disregarding my experience.” When the doula….
  • Social media—along with a keeping-up-with-the-Joneses’-baby mentality that takes hold in certain well-off women’s circles—can make some moms-to-be think that they simply must hire a birth doula.
  • But some women I spoke with described doulas who missed appointments or even the birth of their baby, offered unsound medical advice, and otherwise behaved unprofessionally.
  • The most common complaint I encountered concerned doulas not showing up for all or part of the birth, or behaving in strange, unsupportive ways once they did get there.
  • Her doula, she said, caught only the last 10 or so minutes of her labor, and she didn’t visit after the baby’s birth, as they had agreed on.

How this summary was made: extractive summary — built from the sources' own reporting. It is drawn only from the reporting of the sources listed below — read the originals for full detail. How we summarize →

Advertisement

Every article behind this summary — 1 article from 1 outlet