'Traitors' Season 3 Cast's Unfiltered Thoughts on Danielle Reyes' Behavior
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ad737/ad737898c8285a7283e0992e9e4e248ea8f78aa2" alt="'Traitors' Season 3 Cast's Unfiltered Thoughts on Danielle Reyes' Behavior"
It isn’t just Traitors viewers who are conflicted about Danielle Reyes‘ approach to the game — her season 3 costars are just as confused.
The latest installment of Peacock’s hit series got off to a strong start when Danielle, Bob the Drag Queen and Carolyn Wiger were chosen as Traitors, causing chaos behind the scenes. The situation went even further off the rails once Boston Rob Mariano was brought into the mix, which left everyone at odds.
Boston Rob and Bob the Drag Queen’s Traitor-on-Traitor fighting was tough to watch — but so was Danielle’s very emotional performance in the role of a Faithful. While some found Danielle’s concern that she could be killed off believable, many of her fellow contestants — and fans watching at home — felt she was giving herself away with her over-the-top behavior.
The drama got worse once it was just Danielle and Carolyn left as the last remaining Traitors. Their issues with each other — which stemmed from them both trying to banish the other one from the castle — reached a fever pitch with a heightened roundtable that left Carolyn in tears and Danielle literally shaking when her competitor was unmasked as a Traitor.
All Rules and Behind-the-Scenes Secrets You Didn’t Know About ‘The Traitors’
Despite the offscreen backlash, Danielle stood by her approach.
“That’s all performance and crazy acting,” she told People in February 2025. “I am a non-emotional person in my normal life to the point people think I’m heartless and cold. I’ve been told that. So I decided to cry. I thought I’d be more emotional. I would get emotional at stupid stuff. It’s so cringey. I laugh at myself because it is funny.”
Danielle knew that not everyone would support her gameplay, adding, “It seemed like, ‘What am I doing?’ ‘Oh, you’re an obvious Traitor because you’re not scared,’ but I did act scared. I made my hands shake, but I did put my name up eventually, but it was edited out. My point was to make it seem like I was a Faithful, that’s why I did that.”
She added: “If you listen to people who’ve been murdered and banished, they’re all surprised that I’m a Traitor. I mean, it’d be so boring if I wasn’t doing what I was doing. You don’t want Traitors hugging and singing ‘Kumbaya.’ You want to see the chaos, and that’s what we’re giving you guys.”
Keep scrolling for the most unfiltered cast commentary on Danielle’s performance as a Traitor:
Chanel Ayan
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ad737/ad737898c8285a7283e0992e9e4e248ea8f78aa2" alt="The Traitors Cast Has Been Unfiltered About Danielle Reyes Season 3 Behavior"
During a January 2025 episode of the Traitors aftershow, Ayan had nothing but praise for Danielle, whom she referred to as a “hot grandmother.”
“She has a nice ass for her age. Like it is super up there for a 52-year-old woman,” Ayan quipped. “Her ass made me think she wasn’t a Traitor.”
Chrishell Stause
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ad737/ad737898c8285a7283e0992e9e4e248ea8f78aa2" alt="The Traitors Cast Has Been Unfiltered About Danielle Reyes Season 3 Behavior"
After coming face to face with Danielle when she was murdered on the show, Chrishell was left unimpressed.
“They cut out the fact that Danielle swore on her grandkids. This is going to come out at the reunion. She knew it was going to be aired on the show and she said it multiple times while filming,” Chrishell said on the “Off the Vine” podcast in February 2025. “There [were] factual things she was doing where I was like, ‘This doesn’t add up.’ I was trying to bring these things up. Just think about facts and don’t go with feeling. If someone swears on whatever, don’t listen, just go on facts.”
The Selling Sunset star added: “Gamers [from Big Brother] take it differently. The ones I was talking to trying to get traction that aren’t gamers, take that in a different way. I feel like there’s a moral difference and they can take advantage of people like us that would think that you would never do that.”
Ciara Miller
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ad737/ad737898c8285a7283e0992e9e4e248ea8f78aa2" alt="The Traitors Cast Has Been Unfiltered About Danielle Reyes Season 3 Behavior"
“I was kind of disgusted that she was a Traitor,” the Summer House star exclusively told Us Weekly in February 2025 “I just didn’t respect her game-playing.”
Ciara also pointed to Danielle swearing on her family members. “There were some off-camera swearing on kids, grandkids or whatever, and I just didn’t feel like the stakes were that high,” she claimed. “Granted, I don’t play game shows for a living, so I don’t know, but it just felt ridiculous to me.”
At the time, Ciara also came for Danielle’s acting skills, saying, “The tears were a lot. And I’m like, ‘These people aren’t actually dead.’ And then come to find out [she’s a Traitor]? Like, bitch, you’re doing the killing.”
Sam Asghari Looks Back at 'Sweaty' Tom Sandoval's Actions on 'The Traitors'
Carolyn Wiger
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ad737/ad737898c8285a7283e0992e9e4e248ea8f78aa2" alt="The Traitors Cast Has Been Unfiltered About Danielle Reyes Season 3 Behavior"
Before her banishment — at Danielle’s hands — aired, Carolyn addressed her fellow Traitor’s gameplay.
“I thought it was ridiculous,” she told People in February 2025. “I thought we may not be getting along in the turret, but I thought we were together. I was really loyal to her. That was the person I was working with. Come on, girl!”
Carolyn initially “felt close” with Danielle before she ended up feeling betrayed. She also said Danielle’s fake crying made her “uncomfortable.”
“I don’t believe that we need to emotionally manipulate people on The Traitors,” she added. “I don’t believe we need to swear on our family or our children. I don’t believe we need to cross those moral lines. I watched last season, and this is supposed to be fun. What is this bitch doing?”
Carolyn ultimately found it “hard to watch” the season back. “It was uncomfortable,” she concluded. “They need to cast more clueless-ass people because that’s fun to watch.”
After her exit, Carolyn shared a poem she wrote for Danielle, saying, “Imagine loving this show and being so excited to have fun and play this game and then you show up with your JCPenney hat wanting to play hard. I get it girl but we are not the same. They say that expectations will leave you frustrated and sad. I didn’t expect to be around constant shaking and crying. I guess that was my bad. You are not just a Traitor. You are keeping Visine in business too. I hope those Big Brother fans are proud of you.”
Bob the Drag Queen
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ad737/ad737898c8285a7283e0992e9e4e248ea8f78aa2" alt="'Traitors' Season 3 Cast's Unfiltered Thoughts on Danielle Reyes' Behavior"
“Danielle is an absolute icon in the world of reality TV,” Bob the Drag Queen told People in February 2025 about his fellow Traitor. “I don’t think y’all reading at home know how much Danielle Reyes has changed the game of reality TV. You literally don’t know. They do reality differently because of her impact.”
Nikki Garcia
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ad737/ad737898c8285a7283e0992e9e4e248ea8f78aa2" alt="The Traitors Cast Has Been Unfiltered About Danielle Reyes Season 3 Behavior"
During an interview with Entertainment Weekly in February 2025, Nikki weighed in on Danielle, saying, “The one that sticks out to me the most would be Danielle because when you are trying to act too much, fake cry, and when you look back at the shields. It’s so messy.”
Robyn Dixon
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ad737/ad737898c8285a7283e0992e9e4e248ea8f78aa2" alt="The Traitors Cast Has Been Unfiltered About Danielle Reyes Season 3 Behavior"
“Watching the Traitors, I’m like, ‘OK, you all are a hot mess,’” Robyn exclusively shared with Us in January 2025 about every Traitor. “I actually messaged Carolyn last night. I’m like, ‘You all are a hot mess. Why did you murder me? But you’re a hot mess,’ and you can just see that it’s going to implode, but it’s very compelling television.”
Robyn noted that she thought Carolyn was going to go far “because she was so under the radar” compared to her costars.
The Traitors' Britney and Danielle's 'Big Brother' Drama Explained
Boston Rob
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ad737/ad737898c8285a7283e0992e9e4e248ea8f78aa2" alt="The Traitors Cast Has Been Unfiltered About Danielle Reyes Season 3 Behavior"
“I don’t think [Danielle] is a bad person. I do think she made a lot of mistakes in the game. Her acting was overdone. I picked up on it,” he told Us in February 2025. “It’s like, ‘What are you doing? What Faithful would ever lose the chance to get immunity?'”
Gabby Windey
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ad737/ad737898c8285a7283e0992e9e4e248ea8f78aa2" alt="The Traitors Cast Has Been Unfiltered About Danielle Reyes Season 3 Behavior"
According to Gabby, Danielle is one of the few Traitors costars she didn’t remain in contact with, telling Parade in February 2025, “I don’t think we have each other’s numbers.”
Sam Asghari
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ad737/ad737898c8285a7283e0992e9e4e248ea8f78aa2" alt="The Traitors Cast Has Been Unfiltered About Danielle Reyes Season 3 Behavior"
The actor took it upon himself to give Us some pointers that could have helped Danielle’s performance, sharing, “She shouldn’t be shaking and she shouldn’t be crying. When you cry in acting, the best way to cry is when you actually stop yourself from crying. You kind of hide away. It’s a vulnerable moment, and she was not doing that. She was doing the opposite of that, which makes [her] a terrible actor.”
He added: “She was crying for attention and she was giving Traitor [vibes] throughout the whole season. It just wasn’t the right timing for us to get her, but she’s playing hard and she’s competitive and I give her that.”