The actress stars as Tanya Martin in the 'Dexter' prequel series

The 'Dexter: Original Sin' actress got to see the Eras Tour in Los Angeles and Miami

After watching reboots like '...And Just Like That' and 'Dexter: Original Sin', Gellar said she's realized "there are ways to do it, definitely does get your mind thinking, ‘Well, maybe'"

Gellar tells PEOPLE her teenage self — who is a huge fan of 'Heathers' and 'Can't Buy Me Love' — would be freaking out at her 'Dexter: Original Sin' role

The revival boom keeps going, and Gellar's no longer against the idea of having some more Buffy adventures.

The star said her "deer-in-the-headlights" expression was out of concern of breaking an NDA about 'I Know What You Did Last Summer'

The actress tells PEOPLE she "always" thought it was "such a bummer that I missed my opportunity to be on" the original show

The 'Jersey Shore' star explained to PEOPLE how impactful 'Buffy the Vampire Slayer' was to her

"She comes running in, she's like, 'OH MY GOD!' I'm like, 'What happened?' She's like, 'There's the most beautiful man in the rehearsal hall. I have never… I'm in love!'" Gellar recalled

The actress was visiting her husband Freddie Prinze Jr. on the set of his new movie when she accidentally broke the news that the reboot had begun filming

“Thanksgiving looks a little different this year," Gellar captioned the photos

The Australian actor plays campus heartthrob Lucien Belmont, a.k.a. the Ryan Phillippe-inspired character in the Prime Video remake