The actress, who's Tony-nominated for 'John Proctor Is the Villain,' chats with PEOPLE about Broadway and her new Netflix movie 'Fear Street: Prom Queen'

The pair are taking over from Havana Rose Liu and Kristine Froseth before the play's limited engagement ends in May

"It’s not like I didn’t say, ‘Oh, I’d like to offer my services.’ I did. And for whatever reason, that didn’t happen," said the 'Amateur' actor

Consuelos joins Neve Campbell, Mason Gooding, Isabel May, Joel McHale and more in the upcoming slasher sequel, slated for a February 2026 release

"We hope the oldest one will be chill for the younger two," quipped the actress and 'Sex Lives of College Girls' co-creator